Regarding modern medical alert systems, the choice between the MGM Move from Medical Guardian and the Apple Watch Series 9 is not just about cutting-edge technology. It’s about how these devices can meet your everyday health and safety needs, aligning with your unique lifestyle and preferences. Whether you’re a tech enthusiast or seeking a straightforward safety solution, this comparison is designed to value and consider your personal or family health management strategies, guiding you toward the ideal device that resonates with you.

Apple Watch Series 9

Rating: 4.9
The Apple Watch Series 9 stands out as the best medical alert watch of 2024 for several compelling reasons. Its advanced health monitoring capabilities, including the lifesaving potential of its fall detection and Emergency SOS features, set it apart in a market flooded with options.

The Apple Watch Series 9 continues Apple’s tradition of innovative technology and health-oriented features. As a leading name in the smartwatch market, Apple has designed the Series 9 to be not just an extension of your smartphone but a comprehensive health and fitness companion. It integrates seamlessly with the iOS ecosystem, offering a wide array of features that cater to both daily convenience and emergency situations.

  • Advanced Health Monitoring
  • Superior Fall Detection
  • Emergency SOS
  • Fitness Tracking
  • Always-On Retina Display
  • Water Resistance
Why We Choose It?

The Apple Watch Series 9 stands out as the best medical alert watch of 2024 for several compelling reasons. Its advanced health monitoring capabilities, including the lifesaving potential of its fall detection and Emergency SOS features, set it apart in a market flooded with options. The integration of these features into a device that also excels in daily connectivity, fitness tracking, and personalization offers users a level of versatility and reliability unmatched by competitors. While the price point and battery life may be considerations for some, the overall value and peace of mind provided by the Apple Watch Series 9 make it an unrivaled choice for anyone looking to combine the functionalities of a smartwatch with the critical features of a medical alert system.

Medical Guardian

Rating: 4.8
Embrace a safer tomorrow with Medical Guardian – your trusted partner in personal emergency response

Medical Guardian offers a wide array of devices and features, ensuring there’s an option for nearly any need and budget.

  • Waterproof Durability
  • GPS Functionality
  • Long Battery Life
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Easy-to-Use Interface
  • Lightweight and Comfortable
Why We Choose It?

In selecting the Medical Guardian bracelet for our review, we focused on its standout blend of advanced safety features, user-centric design, and reliability. This choice was driven by its comprehensive coverage, ensuring users feel secure and supported whether at home or on the go.

The waterproof durability, GPS functionality, and long battery life stand out as key reasons, providing peace of mind to a wide range of users—from active adults to seniors living independently. Additionally, its nationwide coverage and easy-to-use interface make it a superior choice for anyone seeking a blend of modern technology with practical, everyday safety. Our commitment to reviewing products that genuinely enhance users’ lives led us to choose the Medical Guardian bracelet, highlighting its role as a reliable guardian in the landscape of medical alert systems.

Brand Overview

Medical Guardian stands out in the personal emergency response system industry, offering a tailored experience with devices like the MGM Move. Known for its robust functionality in health monitoring and emergency assistance, Medical Guardian focuses on reliability and user-centric features, making it a trusted name for seniors and individuals with medical needs.

On the other hand, Apple presents the Apple Watch Series 9, a device that transcends the boundaries of a mere smartwatch. This device seamlessly integrates health, fitness, and connectivity in a sleek package, ensuring you stay connected to your social and professional circles. The Apple Watch Series 9 is not just a tech-savvy user’s staple for a connected lifestyle but also a tool that combats isolation and keeps you engaged.

General Information

2/2 brands
Apple Watch Series 9
Medical Guardian
Overall Rating
Startup Costs
$99 for device purchase + $49.95 activation fee
User Reviews
Mostly positive
Exceptionally high
Ease of Setup
Streamlined and user-friendly
User-friendly, quick installation
Ease of Use
Intuitive operation with a focus on accessibility
Intuitive interface and simple operation
Best for
Seniors living alone, individuals with mobility issues, tech-savvy users seeking comprehensive features

When evaluating the Medical Guardian MGM Move and the Apple Watch Series 9, we find distinct focuses that cater to varied consumer needs and preferences within the health and safety tech market.

The MGM Move, known for its robust emergency response features and user-centric design, is priced at a one-time fee of $99 plus a $49.95 activation fee, making it an affordable option. It boasts a high overall user rating of 4.8/5 due to its reliability and straightforward user experience, reflected in consistently positive reviews. The device is best suited for seniors or individuals with mobility issues, highlighting its simple setup and operation, which allows for ease of use without technological intimidation.

On the other hand, the Apple Watch Series 9 steps beyond traditional boundaries by integrating comprehensive health monitoring and an expansive suite of connectivity features, starting at $399. With an overall rating of 4.9/5, it excels in seamless integration with the iOS ecosystem, offering features like heart rate monitoring, GPS tracking, and the ability to contact emergency services directly. It’s particularly noted for its stylish design and multifunctional capabilities, making it ideal for a younger, more tech-savvy demographic that values aesthetics and functionality.

Both devices are committed to high reliability and user satisfaction but serve distinctly different user bases. The MGM Move is tailored for those needing reliable, immediate emergency assistance with minimal complexity. In contrast, the Apple Watch Series 9 offers an all-in-one lifestyle device that supports a wide range of health and fitness monitoring, paired with the convenience of smartphone connectivity and personalization.

Technical Characteristics

2/2 brands
Apple Watch Series 9
Medical Guardian
Battery Life
Up to 18 hours
24-72 hours, depends on device
Connectivity Type
Wi-Fi, Cellular, LTE, GPS
Wi-Fi, cellular, and landline connections available
Size and Weight
Small and lightweight
Smallest wearable devices on the market
In-home Systems Range
Not Applicable
1,300 ft (about 3 football fields)
Wearable Device Range
Not specified
Customization and Alert Options
Available for all wearable devices
Fall Detection
Water Resistant
All devices are water resistant

When delving into the technical characteristics of the MGM Move and the Apple Watch Series 9, each device presents unique advantages tailored to its target audiences.

The MGM Move is equipped to handle essential safety functions with a battery life spanning 24 to 72 hours, depending on the device, ensuring consistent operation during daily activities. It offers Wi-Fi, cellular, and landline connectivity, facilitating a reliable connection to emergency monitoring services.

The in-home systems are particularly notable for their extensive coverage, offering a range of up to 1,300 feet, which is substantial for ensuring connectivity throughout one’s home.

In contrast, the Apple Watch Series 9 is designed with a more technologically advanced framework, focusing on seamless integration into a user’s daily lifestyle.

The battery supports up to 18 hours of use, which is suitable for a day’s activities but requires nightly charging. It offers advanced connectivity options, including Wi-Fi, LTE, and GPS, allowing for constant connection and precise location tracking, essential for emergency services and daily navigation. The Apple Watch does not have a specific range for in-home use but is globally capable, with features designed to function wherever cellular or Wi-Fi connections are available.

Monitoring and Response

2/2 brands
Apple Watch Series 9
Medical Guardian
24/7 Monitoring Service
Monitoring Center Certification
Not applicable*
Two-Way Voice Communication
Available through integrated cellular connectivity
Available in all on-the-go devices and in MGHome Cellular system
GPS Tracking
Precise location tracking for emergency services
Activity Monitoring
Comprehensive fitness and health activity tracking
Medical Guardian Care Web Portal and Mobile App compatiable
Mobile App Integration
Seamless integration with the Health app on iOS devices
Monitoring & Response Time
Instant alerts and response via Emergency SOS
Fast response

Both devices’ monitoring and response capabilities reflect their core purposes: immediate emergency assistance for the MGM Move and integrated health monitoring for the Apple Watch Series 9.

The MGM Move provides 24/7 monitoring services, ensuring users can access help anytime. This device has two-way voice communication in all on-the-go and in-home cellular systems, allowing for direct communication with emergency operators. The addition of GPS tracking aids in precise location pinpointing during emergencies, which is crucial for fast response times.

Apple’s Watch Series 9, while not a traditional medical alert system, incorporates sophisticated health monitoring technologies. It features an Emergency SOS function that notifies emergency services and predefined contacts when activated. The watch continuously monitors health metrics like heart rate and blood oxygen levels and even includes an ECG function, providing critical data in real-time.

Moreover, its integration with the iOS Health app ensures that all data is readily accessible and can be shared with healthcare providers as needed.

Recommended Blog Posts

Sarah Martinez
3 min
Fall Alert Systems: How They Work and Who Should Have One
Fall alert systems leverage advanced sensors and algorithms to monitor the wearer's movements, capable of distinguishing between everyday activities and falls
Johnatan Lee
9 min
Revolutionizing Elderly Care: The Role of Robotics and Medical Alert Technologies
Discover how robotics and medical alert technologies are reshaping elderly care. Explore the benefits, innovations, and future trends in enhancing daily independence
Emily Thompson
15 min
Keeping Seniors Safe: The Role of Human Activity Recognition in Elderly Care
The evolution of Human Activity Recognition (HAR) in providing care for older adults is not just a technological leap but a necessity, given the demographic shifts we are witnessing globally.

Additional Features

2/2 brands
Apple Watch Series 9
Medical Guardian
Not Applicable*
Multi-User Support
Not directly applicable, but multiple watches can be linked to the same iPhone for family monitoring
Medication Reminders
Available through third-party apps and reminders
Available in some devices
Voice Activation
Siri integration for hands-free commands and alerts
Multilingual Support
Supports multiple languages through Siri

Beyond their primary functions, the MGM Move and Apple Watch Series 9 offer additional features that enhance user experience and safety.

The MGM Move includes features tailored to the needs of its users, such as fall detection technology, which automatically alerts the monitoring center in case of a fall, ensuring that help is dispatched even if the user cannot press the emergency button. Additionally, it offers practical solutions like lockboxes for emergency access, medication reminders, and a mobile app that allows family members or caregivers to monitor the user’s status and receive alerts.

The Apple Watch Series 9 extends its utility beyond health and emergency services by incorporating various daily convenience features. It supports Siri for voice commands, making it easier to set reminders, send messages, or make calls hands-free. The watch also supports third-party apps that can add functionality such as medication reminders and multilingual support, making it a versatile companion for health management and daily activities.

In summary, while the MGM Move and Apple Watch Series 9 are equipped with robust technical characteristics and features, the MGM Move focuses on straightforward emergency response and accessibility for seniors or those with medical needs. In contrast, the Apple Watch Series 9 offers a comprehensive approach to health monitoring and lifestyle integration, suitable for tech-savvy individuals seeking a device that supports a wide array of activities and health metrics.

Customer Service and Support

2/2 brands
Apple Watch Series 9
Medical Guardian
Customer Service Score
Highly rated across various platforms
Devices Maintenance
Comprehensive support through AppleCare+
Returns and Refunds
14-day return policy for online and in-store purchases
Standard one-year warranty, extendable with AppleCare+
Covered by Medical Guardian Protection Plan

The customer service and support systems of the MGM Move and the Apple Watch Series 9 are built around their brand philosophies—Medical Guardian emphasizes direct, accessible support for emergencies. At the same time, Apple focuses on a comprehensive service ecosystem that enhances the overall user experience.

MGM Move prides itself on its dedicated customer support, offering a 9.8/10 service score that showcases its commitment to user satisfaction. The brand ensures 24/7 monitoring from certified centers, with staff trained to handle emergencies efficiently. This round-the-clock support is crucial for users who depend on immediate assistance. Additionally, Medical Guardian provides multilingual support, accommodating a broader range of users. Medical Guardian is responsive and helpful for maintenance and troubleshooting, ensuring that devices function correctly and efficiently.

Apple Watch Series 9 is supported by AppleCare+, which offers an extended warranty and comprehensive support through various channels, including in-store, online, and via phone. Apple’s customer service is highly rated across multiple platforms for its promptness and effectiveness.

The support also includes an extensive online knowledge base and troubleshooting guides, which benefit users looking to solve issues quickly. Apple’s approach integrates seamlessly with its broader ecosystem, providing a service experience that complements its technological offerings.

Latest Guides

Alex Robinson
15 min
Best Medical Alert Watches
Find the Perfect Medical Alert Watch: Compare Prices, Fall Detection, and More
Johnatan Lee
15 min
Best Medical Alerts With Fall Detection
Looking for peace of mind? Explore our Top 5 Medical Alert Systems with Fall Detection. Find the perfect blend of reliability, innovation, and safety tailored for you or your loved ones.
Emily Thompson
10 min reading
Best Medical Alert Bracelets
Dive into our analysis to find the perfect bracelet that meets your safety and lifestyle needs, ensuring peace of mind and independence.

Cost and Value

2/2 brands
Apple Watch Series 9
Medical Guardian
Subscription Plans
Not Applicable*
Monthly, quarterly or annually
Initial Setup Fee
None, except for the cost of the Watch itself (Price of Watch: $399)
$99 for device purchase + $49.95 activation fee
Monthly Fee
Cellular service fees apply for LTE models
Start at $29.95
Extra Services Fees
AppleCare+ optional
Starts at $10/month
Discounts and Offers
Occasional promotions through Apple and retailers
Often. Latest Offer: 75% Off for MGHome products
Trial Period
14-day return policy
30 days

When considering the cost and value offered by the MGM Move and the Apple Watch Series 9, each product caters to different financial expectations and user needs, reflecting their distinct market positions.

MGM Move offers a relatively low initial setup fee of $99 plus a $49.95 activation fee, with monthly monitoring plans starting at $29.95. This pricing structure is straightforward and transparent, with no hidden costs, catering mainly to budgets typical of seniors or those who require a simple, effective emergency response system. The value of the MGM Move is found in its reliability and specialized services, such as fall detection and GPS tracking, which, although they come at an additional cost, provide critical safety features.

Apple Watch Series 9 involves a higher initial cost, starting at $399, reflecting its advanced technological features and brand prestige. There are no monthly fees unless users opt for LTE models, which require an additional cellular service plan. Apple also offers AppleCare+ for an extra charge, providing extended warranty and support. The value proposition of the Apple Watch Series 9 lies in its integration of health tracking, connectivity, and lifestyle management tools, making it a versatile investment that extends beyond mere emergency services.

In summary, the MGM Move is optimized for cost-effective, focused emergency service and support, making it an excellent choice for those who need straightforward, reliable emergency communication.

On the other hand, the Apple Watch Series 9 offers a comprehensive package of health management, connectivity, and tech integration, suitable for users looking for a multifunctional device that supports an active, connected lifestyle. This makes the Apple Watch a higher-priced but more versatile option, ideal for tech-savvy users or those integrating their health management with everyday wearable technology.

Final Thoughts

The comparison between the MGM Move and the Apple Watch Series 9 underscores the diversity in today’s wearable technology market, particularly in how different devices cater to specific needs, ranging from dedicated medical alert functionalities to broader lifestyle and health management features.

MGM Move is primarily designed for individuals who prioritize safety and emergency responsiveness. Its robust customer service, straightforward cost structure, and features like 24/7 monitoring, fall detection, and GPS tracking make it particularly suitable for seniors or those with medical conditions who require a dependable emergency support system. The device is optimized for ease of use, offering peace of mind to users and their families through a simple, functional design that focuses on swift emergency responses.

Apple Watch Series 9, on the other hand, represents a leap into the future of integrated personal technology. It combines extensive health monitoring—including heart rate tracking, ECG, and oxygen level sensors—with everyday connectivity and intelligent features supported by the iOS ecosystem. The higher initial cost reflects its advanced capabilities and stylish design, which appeal to a tech-savvy audience looking for a device that blends health management with comprehensive digital integration.

For those evaluating these options:

  • Choose MGM Move if you need a reliable, cost-effective solution focused on health safety and emergency responsiveness. It’s ideal for those who want a device that performs well in critical situations without the need for additional features that extend beyond medical alert needs.
  • Opt for the Apple Watch Series 9 if you want a multifunctional smartwatch that helps manage health and fitness and keeps you connected to your digital life. It’s perfect for individuals who are comfortable with technology and desire a device that supports various activities and provides insights into overall wellness.

Ultimately, the choice between these two products will depend on the individual’s specific needs, lifestyle, and how they prioritize the features of their ideal medical alert system or smartwatch. Each device offers unique benefits, and the decision should align with what best enhances the user’s quality of life and safety requirements.

Compare Other Brands